hypercritical

"'Tis rude to laugh" is another precept of the hypercritical mother.

A little pruning—a few sharp experiences, and hypercritical indeed would be the judgment that should find room for blame.

Was it desperation, defiance, an indifferent resolve to give him one last chance—or his own hypercritical fancy?

I may say, though this is hypercritical, that the name of Don Juan is a mistake.